A/N: This chapter follows on from the fight scene at school. This was the original ending I had planned for this fic. This is how it truly ends 😉
Shouto slammed into Dabi, the slimmer ravenette recoiling before catching himself and lunging forward again, throwing a well placed punch to Shouto’s jaw, the duel haired heartthrob being sent flying into the lockers nearby.
Suddenly you were between them.
“STOP!” You screamed, holding your hands up, one palm towards Dabi, one palm towards Shouto. “ENOUGH!”
Shouto stayed up against the lockers, his chest heaving with exertion.
Dabi walked right up so that his torso was against your palm.
“I said, ‘stop’.” You growled lowly, your narrowed eyes locking onto him threateningly.
“Oh? My pet is protection her young. How cute.” Dabi sneered.
You turned and kicked him in the shins.
“DON’T BITE YOUR MASTER!” Dabi yelled sharply.
“Master?!” Shouto said in shocked surprise, his eyes widening as he looked at you for an explanation.
“Ah fuck.” You grunted. “Ok, you two, lets go.” You said, storming off and looking back at them. “Come NOW or you’re both gonna get caught by the principal for fighting and get detention or suspension.
Shouto and Dabi looked at each other then followed you. You led them off down to the other end of the hallway so you could all talk in private.
“Ok.” You said with a heavy sigh, “time to open this can of worms.”
“What’s going on?” Shouto asked curiously.
“Sho, I was the one who broke your project.” You admitted glumly as your gaze fell to the floor. “I didn’t mean to, I was in the classroom because I had written you an apology note and wanted to put it in your bag but couldn’t find your bag anywhere and I tripped and smashed into your desk and your project went flying and and… well … Dabi saw it happen.” You said, looking across at Dabi who smirked and crossed his arms.
“Damn right I did.” He said in a mischievously low tone.
Shouto shot him an annoyed look then turned back to you.
“Y/N, it’s ok, I’m not mad anymore. All is forgiven.” He said in a monotone yet reassuring voice.
You let out the breath you had been holding.
“Thanks Sho, I’m so sorry. I should have told you sooner.” You said regretfully. “I was just scared you would hate me and not believe that it was an accident. I tried to tell you so many times but every time I tried it just never came out…”
Shouto shook his head. “Y/N, I could never hate you.” He said with a soft smile.
Your heart melted.
“But what’s this ‘master’ thing?” Shouto said, a hint of jealousy in his voice.
“Well, asswipe here.” You said gesturing you Dabi, “saw me and I asked him not to tell you and he promised he wouldn’t… if I became his pet.”
Dabi sniggered. “And she was becoming such a good pet, so good I was going to make her my girlfriend.” He said.
“Keep dreaming Dabi, she would never go for you.” Shouto shot at him.
“Oh wouldn’t she?” Dabi leered. “Guess I’ll just have to keep that quiet then won’t I.”
Shouto raised an eyebrow at him then looked at you for an answer.
“Sho… I… I don’t know how to say this…” you started as you hung your head.
“You slept with him didn’t you.” Shouto said bluntly.
“NO!” You yelled, “No! No I definitely didn’t… but… we did do… things.” You said remorsefully as you hung your head back down again.
There was silence from the two boys and you took a deep breath in.
“I’m sorry. I’m calling it off with the two of you. I’ve been an idiot. I don’t deserve you Sho and I don’t want to hurt you by choosing Dabi so I’m gonna go solo.”
You stared at the floor.
“Well…. that was shit.”
Tears welled up in your eyes.
“Y/N, if I told you I was willing to share would you still be with me?” Shouto asked suddenly.
Your head shot up.
“WHAT?!” You and Dabi both yelled in unison.
Shouto didn’t even acknowledge Dabi.
“I don’t want to let you go.” He said softly to you.
Your mind was reeling.
“S-share?! As in… have 2 boyfriends?”
Your mouth had been opening and closing but no words had come out yet.
“Excuse me, what?” Dabi asked Shouto again. “Have I got this right? You want to share Y/N is that right?”
“Woah, ok, look I don’t swing that way…” Dabi said, holding his hands up defensively to Shouto.
“I’m not interested in you, I want Y/N. And if I have to share her to keep her then so be it.” Shouto said darkly to Dabi. “Unless you want to concede?”
“Fuck no, I’m not conceding!” Dabi snorted, “give up my pet? I don’t think so!”
“I thought I was going to be your girlfriend?” You shot at Dabi, crossing your arms and raising an eyebrow.
“Minor details.” Dabi said dismissively. “So Y/N? Did you need to think about it?”
You looked at Shouto then Dabi then back to Shouto.
“Look… I really don’t know how this is going to work out but… if you’re both ok with it then… I guess we can give it a go?”
Dabi smirked. “I’m definitely the top.”
“Oh are you now?” You replied sarcastically.
“Burnt chicken is always on the bottom of the sandwich.” Shouto shot at Dabi with an almost bored expression.
“Who the fuck has burnt chicken on their sandwich?” Dabi retorted.
“I said burnt because you look li-.”
“boys! BOYS! OH MY GOD SHUT UP!” You yelled with exasperation. “If I hear any more bickering out of you I’ll be topping both of you.”
“Not gonna lie that sounds hot.” Dabi replied you, not skipping a beat.
“Ok. Is this a deal? We’re all boyfriends and girlfriends then?” You snapped.
Shouto nodded and Dabi grunted a ‘yeah’
“Good!” You said. “We can work out finer details later. I was getting sick of wavering between the two of you. Now I don’t need to worry about that any more.