To Get You Back – Erza x Male!Reader

“Requip!” Erza called, her body floating off the ground then glowing a yellow-white before taking form in her new combat outfit.

“I will never NOT get enough of her requiping into my favourite outfit,” you thought as you gazed at her leopard print cat ears that were pressed flat and back against her head a little, giving the look for being angry and focused.

“Come!” she called, swiping her sword across her front and setting it back on her right side-tip pointed to you, ready to attack should you make a move.

“Oh, that’s right we’re in the middle of a duel,” you thought as you straightened a bit, your shadow Jaguar staying crouched in combat mode by your side, “listen, I know I said I wanted to duel but I actually just wanted to talk… about us.”

“You asked for a rematch,” she said darkly, “now are you going to fight me or not.”

“No. I’m sorry. I just asked for a rematch so I could get you alone,” you admitted.

Erza didn’t react, keeping her eyes on you lest this be some kind of trick to get her to let her guard down.

You sighed, “you don’t seem to show me any special attention even though we have had a relationship in the past.”

“Shut up and fight me!” she snapped, jumping forward in a fit of rage.

“Come now,” you said calmly as you swiped two fingers in front of you and your Jaguar launched at Erza’s outstretched sword, biting it swiftly in half the minute it’s jaws settled around the sturdy item, “you still seem angry about it, even though I’ve already told you the truth.”

“You sleep in a den of lies,” she hissed, tossing the rest of the broken sword away and punching you in the face.

Your shadow Jaguar spun on its haunches and lunged at Erza, tackling her to the ground and pinning her there.

“You seriously believe I would cheat on you?” you asked, a little annoyed that she had allowed such a trickery of magic fool her, “you know that that wizard was just creating imagination magic to break us apart.” 

“No. I know you cheated,” she growled, trying to get her arms free from under your Jaguar’s grasp. 

“I can’t believe you still believe that, even though he admitted tricking you and removed the spell.”

“You flirt with everyone,” she growled, “you never loved me.”

“You’re the only one I have ever loved. That’s why I haven’t been with anyone else since,” you admitted, calling your Jaguar off her, ” but I can’t keep this up. It hurts that you won’t accept me back even though I know you still have feelings for me.”

“I do not!” she blushed, looking away to hide the emotions showing plainly on her face.

“Well this is goodbye then. I’m leaving the guild,” you said, calling your Jaguar back to your side and giving it the command to heel as you turned and walked away.

“That’s it?!” she exploded, “you still haven’t fought me sincerely yet!” 

“What’s the point,” you called back over your shoulder, not looking back, “I can’t be around you. It hurts too much.”

Suddenly you were whacked in the back by something heavy and you fell face first into the ground.

“Oof!” you grunted, coughing a little.

Your Jaguar instantly attacked the thing that had landed on your back- Erza- and bit into her arm as it fought her away from you.

“Jikor!” you called your pet, “let her go!”

Your black shadow pet immediately let Erza go and slunk back to your side.

“Sorry,” you said as you sat up and then stood and walked over to her to help her up, “I didn’t know you were going to jump me like that. He did that all on his own he was just trying to protec—,” you stopped mid-sentence when you saw she was tearing up from her left eye and you quickly knelt by her side, “I’m sorry, did he hurt you bad? Let me see.”

“It’s not from his bite,” she said in a quivering voice, “I don’t want you to leave to guild.”

“Erza, I can’t stay here,” you said regretfully, “it hurts. It hurts that you don’t believe me and it hurts that you won’t even give me a chance to prove myself.”

“I….” she couldn’t get it out. It was true that she still loved you but that image the wizard had planted in her memory still lived on and she felt sick to her stomach wherever she was around you.

“Wait,” you said suspiciously, “do you still see the image? That lie that he imbedded in your memory?”

She nodded sadly.

“That lying bastard! He said he had removed it!” You growled, “I’m going to kill him.”

“No! Dont!” Erza said, “please. Take me to a healer, if they can remove it then I should be ok. My mind is still telling me not to trust you but my heart really wants to.”

“Hold on,” you said as you scooped your arms under her legs and behind her back, picking her up bridal style, “we’ll get you help, “hang onto me.”

Tenderly she wrapped her arms around your neck and buried her face into your chest as you bolted back to the guild.

It didn’t take long to find the healer you would need for the magic exorcism and you arrived on the elderly lady’s doorstep within the hour.

In a few short sentences you explained what had happened with Erza and the lady nodded.

“Fear not, young man, if it is a spell that has been imbedded I can remove it. But if it is a true memory I will not be able to erase it.”

“See,” you said to Erza, “if it disappears from your mind will you believe me then?”

“Yes, of course,” she replied with a nod.

You lay her down on the bed and the lady began her work while you watched from the sidelines, your Jaguar, Jikor, remaining silently by your side.

It was only a few short minutes later that Erza awoke and she looked at you then smiled softly- her beautiful closed lip smile was a rare sight.

“Y/N. It’s gone. You were right. You were telling the truth all along. I’m so so sorry,” she said as she sat up.

“Please rest now,” the elderly lady said, “there is a room upstairs you can use to rest in until she has all of her strength back.”

“Thank you so much,” you said gratefully as you tenderly lifted Erza up and held her body to yours as you made for the stairs.

You got to the room in question and opened the door.

“Jikor, stay on watch,” you directed your shadow pet and the Jaguar turned and sat on guard at the door as you closed it softly behind you.

No sooner had the door closed, Erza’s soft lips were pressed to yours.

Stumbling a little you got to the large bed in the room and fell down on top of her, kissing her back passionately.

“I missed you so much,” you whispered amid kisses as you peppered them down her body and over her ample breasts- of what was exposed.

“Y/N. First I must apologize for my behavior. I should have known I was still being manipulated by—.”

Your lips against hers silenced her and her eyes widened a little before she accepted the kiss and parted her lips.

“Don’t apologize. It’s all over now, let’s move on,” you whispered kindly.

“Together,” she whispered back, that tender smile gracing her lips once again.

Overflowing with love for her, you kissed her deeply a little longer, your fingers tracing down her sides as she caressed your back and up into the back of your hair.

“It’s been so long since I got to hold her like this,” you thought nostalgically, your mind casting back to the last time you and Erza had had sex.

Getting intimate with Erza was amazing. It always had been.

“I’ve missed your touch,” she admitted quietly into your ear as you kissed down her neck and headed for her breasts again, tugging the leopard print fabric down to expose her pert pink nipple.

Like a moth drawn to flame, your mouth latched onto it, sucking needily as she took some deep, sigh-like, erotic breaths, her hands cupping the back of your head as you sucked harder.

“Y/N,” she breathed, arching her top half against your mouth, “I….”

Her body spoke the rest of her sentence and you could feel the heat gathering between her thighs, drawing your hand to it.

Down her front and over the soft fabric you touched, remembering just where to press and rub as you continued to suck on her nipple.

Soft light moans escaped her lips as you rubbed and touched, your own erection painfully hard by now and straining at you boxers- begging to be released.

It was almost as if she knew you were in sexual agony and she reached between your legs then cupped your balls in her hand, squeezing gently before palming your cock.

“Do you think it would be safe to…” your voice trailed off as you looked back at the door.

“I think so, Jikor is there guarding,” she whispered in reply, “I really do need you inside me… right now…”

That’s all you needed to hear and in a flurry of arms and legs the two of you ditched your clothes immediately and were writhing naked on the bed, your pre-cum making a mess all over her clit as you arched your cock back and forth over her little bud.

“I’ve missed you,” you groaned lowly as you reached down and slipped your hand under one of her thighs and raised her leg up and out a little so that you could push up into her pussy.

“I’ve missed you too,” she panted, the soft hot walls of her core encasing you as you gently pushed your girth all the way up inside her.

She bit into her bottom lip as you bottomed out and your eyes rolled with delight.

“God, this pussy…” you moaned softly.

“I’m only complete with you inside me,” she whispered, pulling your head down to hers so that she could nibble your ear and lobe as you rocked back and forth ontop of her, still holding her one leg up against your hip.

“Erza,” you whispered erotically, “the things you do to me…”

“Our bodies belong together,” she whispered back, arching her hips up to yours everytime you thrust into her.

You kissed her neck then sat up, raising her legs up straight and opening them out so that you could look down and watch your cock sliding in and out of her tight hole.

“Damn this view is amazing.” Your eyes travelled up to her breasts, delighting in them jiggling every time you thrust into her.

“Faster,” she mewled, grabbing for her breasts and rolling her nipples in between thumb and forefinger.

You obeyed and picked up the pace, rocking rhythmically against her pussy.

“Fuck,” you whispered, looking up at the ceiling as you held her legs out a little further.

“H-Harder,” she begged, one hand sliding down her front so that she could toy with her clit while the other hand furiously tugged on her nipple. 

“Oh fuck, yes,” you groaned, smacking into her at a furious pace.

“Y/N, I’m…” her legs shook violently and she bit into her bottom lip again, throwing her head back against the bedsheets in silent climax.

“I’m close,” you panted fervently.

“Cum inside me,” she begged, “please.”

With relief you released, cum shooting into her and filling her up as you bit back a satisfied moan then dropped her legs down and flopped forward onto your arms, caging her lower half in.

“I want us to be a family,” she whispered, “you’re the only one for me.”

“I’m so happy to have you back,” you panted with a gentle look on your face, “my scarlet.”

~ END ~

<<< A Sixty-Nine? – Juvia x Fem!Reader

Simp (Part 3) – Laxus x Fem!Reader >>>