Competing For You – Eita Semi x Bi!Fem!Reader

You had a crush on two people.

Weird, right?

And they both liked you back.

What?! Is this a fictional story or…?? 

One crush was a really close girl friend from high school and the other crush was Eita Semi, a classmate in your music studies group in college. 

…………………………..

“What if I came by after class?” Your girl friend asked in a provocative tone, her soft sweet voice caressing your ear. 

“Oh?” You leered, sitting straighter on the garden ledge as you smiled up at the sky. “And then what?” 

“Well?” She said with a little seductive chuckle, “we could make out in the band room?” 

“That’s so random.” You replied with a confused laugh, “why the band room?”

“So I can play you like a flute.” She replied with a devious chuckle.

“Ohhhh? I see how it is.” You sneered with a smirk. “Ok, let’s do it, my class finishes at 5pm.”

“I’ll see you then.” She replied before hanging up. 

You smiled to yourself and hung up the phone, looking around before jumping off the wall and heading to class.

“Y/N.” Semi called to you as you entered the classroom, “sit with me.” 

You gave him a bashful smile as you walked over and sat down in the chair next to him, elated that he had watched you from the corner of his eye the whole time you were walking over to him.

“Ahhhh he’s so hot!” you squealed internally as you turned your attention to the front of the classroom. 

The music class went by painfully slowly and you kept watching the clock, praying time would move faster as you imagined your girl friend, not yet your actual girlfriend, with her beautiful face between your thighs, licking and sucking on all your most sensitive areas.

You bit your bottom lip and crossed your legs, college skirt riding up slightly as the heat gathered between your thighs, panties already getting damp at the thought of her going down on you.

Semi kept stealing glances at you throughout the lesson, hypnotized by the subtle things you did. He didn’t want to admit just how into you he was but he was definitely ready to make a move.

Being in the Shiratorizawa volleyball club in highschool meant he had a sharp eye for things and he sensed you were impatient about something but he couldn’t tell what.

Finally class ended and you gathered your things together and stood up, intending to meet your girl outside and wait there for a few minutes before coming back to the empty classroom once everyone had gone. 

“Y/N,” Semi called as you exited the classroom, “I’d like to talk to you.”

“Yes?” You asked as you stopped and looked back at him.

“If you wouldn’t mind, may we spend some time together? I would like to get to know you more.” He said in a firm, stoic voice as he held his arms by his side and bowed slightly. 

“Oh!” You said with a blush, “umm, yes I would love to but I’m meeting up with a… friend… today…”

“I see.” He replied, his sharp brown eyes  locking onto yours, “would tomorrow be better?”

“Yes it would.” You said with a gentle smile, “let’s talk tomorrow and make plans then.”

“Ok.” He said with a small nod, his facing showing no emotion as he turned and walked away.

You were slightly torn but decided to go and meet your girl friend and continue with the original plans as you turned and continued out of the building to meet her.

She smiled brightly when she saw you and you shared a sneaky kiss before heading back to the building, hand in hand.

“Is everyone gone?” She asked in a whisper as you slid the classroom door open and peeked inside.

“Yep.” You replied in a hushed tone, giving her a wink before pulling her in behind you by the hand. 

She giggled as you spun her around and pushed her up against the blackboard at the front of the room, tongues connecting and a heavy make out session commencing while your hands roamed her body and hers roamed yours. 

“Should we lock the door?” She asked breathlessly as you pulled apart to take a breath. 

“My apologies.” A voice said from the door and your head whipped towards the opening to see who it was. 

Your heart sank when you saw Semi there.

“I-I’m sorry, Semi,” you said quickly, “sorry you had to see that.” 

“What are you apologizing for?” He asked in an even tone as he entered the room and slid the door closed behind him, his eyes never leaving you.

“That you had to see me and my friend, kissing,” you said softly with a blush.

“Why would that have mattered?” He asked curiously.

“Well… I know that you like me, and I like you too, I like both of you,” you said as you looked at your friend with an apologetic look.

“Why are you seeing this as an issue? This is an opportunity.” Semi said as he looked at your friend.

Her eyes widened.

“Hey wow, wait a minute, are you suggesting…?”

“I’m issuing a challenge.” Semi said in a firm voice, a small scowl on his face as he looked at her, “who can give Y/N a bigger orgasm.”

“sorry what?!” You gasped in shock, jaw falling open, “hold up, are you meaning have like a threesome?!”

You stepped back from your girl friend, eyes flicking wildly between her and Semi as they smirked at each other.

“W-Where would we do this?” You suddenly blurted out. 

“Here.” They both replied at the same time as they looked from each other back to you.

“Here?!” You punctuated sharply, “what if-.”

“No one will walk in, I’ll lock the door.” Semi said quickly.

“Ok, well if you two are keen?” You replied hesitantly; that turned on throb immediately infiltrating your core. 

Semi nodded and walked back to the door, locking it before gesturing for you and your girl friend to head down behind the band stand nearby.

There was a comfortable little space behind the stand section that was away from any windows or doors and you felt devious yet safe, getting down and dirty with Semi and your friend behind there. 

“Ladies first.” Semi said in a soft tone as he watched you sit down on the floor, your friend kneeling down before crawling over to you and locking lips with you. 

“Ok, so we’re getting to it quickly, that’s cool.” You thought with a bit of panic as your tongue intertwined with your friend’s and your palms hit the floor behind you.

You closed your eyes and let yourself go, focusing on her and what she was doing to you. 

Slowly she laid you back so that you were flat on the floor and kissed down your neck and over your clothes, making her way down your body and in-between your thighs.

You reached down and pulled your skirt up, allowing her soft lips to connect with your inner thigh, a small sigh of pleasure escaping your lips as your head rolled back and rested on the floor.

Semi watched from the sidelines, seated on a small step as your friend ran her nails along your soft skin, up your leg.

Slowly she made her way up to your panties and ran her nails tenderly across the slightly damp fabric there; a shaky light moan shimmering from your parted lips as she touched you.

“How am I doing so far?” Your friend asked you as her mischievous eyes locked with yours once you had re-opened them and lifted your head to look down at her.

“Amazing.” You moaned with a smile.

“I can do better.” Semi said bluntly from the sidelines.

“Oh can you now?” Your friend challenged him, “well then let me see what you’ve got.” 

You watched them switch places, your friend touching herself through her jeans as she sat where Semi had sat and watched him kneel down and run his tongue up your inner thigh, the wickedly erotic sensation causing you to gasp.

“I didn’t know he could do stuff like this?” you thought as he made his way up to your panties and kissed the dampened fabric, inhaling your warm scent. 

“How is he doing?” Your friend asked you as she sat back and rubbed her clit through her jeans. 

“Amazing,” you moaned, “you’re both amazing.”

“I won’t have us both be on the same level.” Semi said bluntly as he pulled back and looked at your friend, “I’m going to be the best.”

You propped yourself up on your elbows and watched as he gripped onto the sides of your panties and pulled them down and off, tenderly spreading your legs again as he kissed his way back up to your glistening pussy.

“Ahhh~.” You wailed, head rolling back as his tongue swiped over your clit, “Semi, your tongue is so soft and warm.” 

“Let me have a go.” Your friend said as she quickly knelt down and pushed Semi aside.

“No, this is my turn, wait your turn.” He grunted, trying to hold his ground.

“No fighting.” You said sharply, “let her have a go.” You said, gesturing to your friend to take her position between your knees. 

She did so as Semi pulled back and dipped her head down, licking and sucking your clit into her mouth while she ran her tongue over it.

“Ohhhh~.” You wailed, flopping back onto the floor and arching into her mouth as she pleasured you with her tongue.

You felt a power struggle as Semi pushed your friend aside again and took her place, copying what she had done to you but then also dipping his tongue into your pussy. 

Back and forth they went, each one bringing that little bit extra to the plate when it was their turn. 

“Can I scissor?” Your friend panted as she stood up and dropped her jeans and panties, “I’m so fucking wet, I need a release.” 

“Yeah sure.” You panted as Semi pulled back from you.

“I will allow her to scissor you, if I can have a turn afterwards.” He said softly, his brown eyes flashing with lust. 

“Fingers or dick?” You asked him as your friend maneuvered herself between your legs and pushed her now bare pussy up against yours, sliding back and forth while your clits rubbed together. “Ahhhh, yes babe,” you moaned softly as you turned your attention to her, “I love your pussy.”

“I’m happy with whatever you would like.” Semi said as he pulled his pants down and stroked his rock hard cock, pre-cum dripping from the tip of it. 

“Dick please.” You moaned, gripping onto your friends leg as she rocked harder down onto you. 

Semi waited his turn and watched you and your friend grind on each other, soft moans and pants filling the empty room as you both got closer and closer to orgasm.

“I have an idea.” You panted as you placed a hand on her leg to slow her down, “you go underneath me and I’ll go on top and Semi you can do me doggy style.” 

“Ok.” He said as you flipped your friend over and onto her back, laying yourself down on top of her and rocking your hips together to create a little more friction.

Semi waited until you had rubbed on each other a bit before he knelt down behind you and spread your legs, pushing his cock all the way into your tight little pussy then leaning over you and resting his weight onto your backside to help push your clit down onto your friend’s.

“Oh god, this feels so good.” You wailed, your fingers intertwining with your friends as you pushed her hands up above her head and leaned your head down to kiss her while Semi thrust into you from behind, his thrusts making you rock against your friend’s pussy.

Through heavy kissing, panting and moaning you and your friend came hard, shaking with euphoria as the orgasm took over your bodies. 

“Oh my god that was so good!” You exclaimed as Semi pulled out of you and sat back, rock hard cock still on display. 

“I’ll say.” Your friend panted from under you, “you win this round, Semi.” She said to the guy behind you. 

“I feel as if I did not win.” He said, looking down at his twitching dick. 

“Awww, come here,” you pouted apologetically as you laid yourself back and invited him to enter you again.

He crawled forwards and pushed his cock into your pussy while you locked your legs over his back and lay back with him on top.

“You can cum in me if you want, I’m on the pill.” You said softly as your lips tenderly met his.

He nodded as he returned the kiss, his hips rocking back and forth as he thrust into you.

It wasn’t long before he came and he let out a small cry before scrunching his eyes shut and shuddering; his hot load shooting into you. 

“That was really beautiful to watch.” Your friend commented as she pulled her panties and pants back on.

“We make a good team, us 3.” You commented slyly.

“I would not be against it happening again.” Semi said in his usual even tone. 

You and your friend exchanged devious glances.

“Ok.” You replied in unison. 

~ END ~

<<< Across his lap (part 2) – Iwaizumi x Fem!Reader

Sunday morning – Ennoshita Chikara x Fem!Reader >>>