Chaotic Good – Karma x Bi!Fem!Reader x Nakamura

The three of you had always been a force to be reckoned with in high school. It went with it saying that you were always up for flirtations and fun. Karma, Nakamura, and you would get a kick out of pretending to be heavily attracted to each other just to make each other jealous and it would just escalate until one of the other class members would step in and tell you all to cut it out.

But highschool had ended now and time had swiftly moved on. 

You hadn’t seen Karma or Rio, as you called her by her first name, in years- but when a house party was arranged at Karma’s place, you couldn’t wait to get there.

“I wonder if it will be just like old times?” you thought, thinking back to some of the fun times you had had in the past as you got ready for the party.

Finally the time came to leave and you dressed yourself up, kinda wanting to impress them or catch their eye.

“Guess that’s the joy of being Bi. If Karma wants me then I’ll take it …. but if Rio wants me more… then I’m more than happy to cross over to the girls.”

8pm sharp you were on the doorstop of Karma’s residence and could already hear the party inside.

He answered the door- his longer, slicked back, red hair falling forward and half covering one eye as he gave you a sexy lopsided grin and leaned on the doorframe.

“Well, well,” he said in a teasing tone, “time has been good to you, Y/N, you’re looking fine as ever.”

His yellow-gold eyes travelled down your body then back up to your face and he smirked as he allowed the tip of his tongue to swipe along the underside of his top lip.

“Hmm?” you hummed with seductive playfulness, “you’ve always been hot, Karma, but maybe not as hot as Nakamura… is she here yet?”

“Yeah, she’s here, but she hasn’t seen you yet so you’re mine for the night.” He stepped forward and scooped his arm around you, pressing his palm into your lower hand to force you to close the gap between the two of you and your head snapped up as your chest hit his.

“Oh so this is how we’re gonna play tonight then, hmmm?” You thought as a cheeky smirk played on your lips, “we’re teasing Nakamura tonight by acting close.”

“Come and let me show you off,” he said as he took his other arm off the frame of the door and placed his hand under your chin then leaned down a little as if he were going to kiss your lips, his movements making your eyes flutter shut.

Instead of his lips touching yours, it was his sadistic little chuckle that lilted into your ear, the hot air from his exhaled chuckle dusting your lips.

“Ohh? You thought I was gonna kiss you. You’ve gone soft,” he mused.

“Shut up,” you snapped, your eyes flinging open as you stepping back from him in a huff, shoving him in his chest, “screw you, I’m going to Nakamura now.”

You tossed your head high in the air and marched past him into the house, looking for Nakamura.

She was chilling on the lounge with some of the other ex-classmates but jumped up with a screech of excitement when she saw you.

“Y/N!!” She squealed, jumping the lounge to get to you.

“Hey baby!” you called, giving her a big squeeze once she had bounded into your arms.

You turned a little so that you could see Karma in the corner of your eye then put her down on the ground again and slid your hands to her ass.

“Karma is watching,” you whispered into her ear and she nodded.

“Oooo, Y/N, you want me like that, huh?” she said in a very loud voice, turning her head to look at Karma.

He was indeed watching and his eyes were ablaze with a passion that you couldn’t quite name but his facial expressions remained neutral with a semi cocked sadistic smirk. Was it jealousy or anger flashing in his eyes… Or maybe it was both?” 

“Mmmm,” Nakamura hummed again, “let’s take this to the bedroom?”

“Oh sure!” you replied loudly, still looking at Karma while squeezing Nakamura’s ass in hand, “I want you so bad, Rio.”

“Ohhhhh,” she fake moaned loudly and you noticed Karma twitch. It was subtle but it was there.

Playing the part, you bent your head and bit into her neck.

“Get a room!” Terasaka called out, a few of the others laughing and cheering with his loud comment.

“Can I come too?!” Okajima shouted as you took Nakamura’s hand in yours and headed for the hallway, pretending you were going to go to one of the rooms.

“Byeee~,” you sung to the rest of the ex-classmates as you and Nakamura chuckled and giggled, running out of sight.

“Oh my god, Rio,” you hissed with laughter once in the hall, “I’m so sure Karma bought that, you act so well.”

“Who says I’m acting?” she leered, slapping you on the bum once you stopped outside one of the rooms.

You laughed, brushing her comment off and were about to walk with her back to the others when your way was blocked by a tall red-headed figure.

“Karma!” you gasped with surprise, nearly bumping into him, as he seemed to have appeared silently out of nowhere, “you’re interrupting my time with Nakamura,” you added sassily, taking her hand in yours again.

“It’s my turn now,” he said in a low, serious tone, reaching out and taking your other hand in his and pulling on it sharply, making you stumbled towards him and shifting Nakamura from where she stood too.

“Back off, Karma, she’s with me,” your blond friend snapped sharply, making you look at her with confused surprise.

“Actually, met her at the door,” Karma replied with a smirk, “I laid claim to her first.”

“Whatever, she likes girls anyway so you have no chance. She’s just messing with you.”

“Woah? Guys,” you chuckled with confusion, interjecting into their verbal fight, “calm down, we’re just mucking around, right?”

“You’re a bit naive if you think we’re just joking, Y/N,” Karma said, pulling on your hand again.

“And I’m telling you, she likes me. Don’t you Y/N,” Nakamura queried.

“Wait. Hold on. I’m confused. I thought we were just messing around here… are you telling me that you two are actually competing for me?” you asked, your head whipping back and forth between the two as they started pulling on your hand in different directions. 

“You’re only just picking up on that now?” Nakamura asked with surprise, “I thought you knew I had a thing for you all along?”

“See, that’s how unappealing you are,” Karma taunted, “she’s really got it for me, hey Y/N.”

“Stop!” you yelled, yanking your hands free from both of them, “I like both of you, ok?! I’m not gonna take sides.”

The pair looked at you, then at each other, then shrugged.

“Fine by me,” Karma replied, “let’s go to my room.”

“Done deal,” Nakamura said with a smirk, “I get to go down on Y/N though.”

“Nah, she’s getting the dick,” Karma replied.

“GUYS!” you snapped, “I … as in- me… I….will be the one who decides what goes where, seeing as I’m the one you both want. So if you don’t agree with that, then you can leave.”

“No complaints here,” Karma said with a smirk.

“Fine,” Nakamura added, “it’s a good thing you’re hot, Karma, I wouldn’t mind messing around with you too even though I just want Y/N.”

“Less talk, more action,” you said, taking the lead, “Karma where is your room?”

He pointed to his door which was the next one over to where you were all standing and you walked over and opened it then followed him and Nakamura in.

“Clothes off,” you said, snapping your fingers, “easiest if we just get naked.”

“This has escalated really quick but I’m not complaining,” Karma mused, locking his door as Nakamura started to strip.

“Shit look at her body!” You groaned internally, watching as Nakamura took her clothes off.

She smirked at your bulging eyes as she slid her panties down and off, then beckoned you to come closer.

You took your top and pants off but left your panties on as you stepped over to her and her hands claimed your waist and ass- pulling your body against hers as she pressed her bare pussy to your panties.

“Mmmm,” you hummed, scooping up under her breasts and squeezing them gently before craning your head down and placing her left nipple in your mouth.

“Oh, Y/N,” she moaned softly, tilting her head back as she rolled her hips into yours and squeezed your ass in hand, using her palms and scrunched fingertips to hold you so she could grind her front to yours.

While you girls humped and you licked and sucked on Nakamura’s nipples, Karma stripped off then walked around behind you.

“These are going,” he commented as he took each side of your panties in hand then tugged them down as he crouched, his face right at pussy height as you poked your ass out at him.

His hot hands roamed your ass, feeling your shape as you kept sucking on Nakamura’s left tit and you shuffled your legs back a little to present your pussy to him in case he wanted to have a little lick.

You let out a soft airy moan as his hands gripped your hips and you let him pull your hips back further from hers so that he could run his tongue up your inner thigh.

“Ohhh, Karma,” you moaned louder, lifting your mouth from Nakamura’s breast to utter his name.

She leaned her head down and her mouth met yours, kissing you fervently while Karma teased you, touching and licking all around your pussy and ass hole, not allowing you to have what you wanted.

“Bed?” she asked airily once she had pulled back from the kiss.

You nodded, unable to speak as Karma stood up behind you and slapped you on the ass.

“Get on the bed, Y/N,” his low voice commanded.

Nakamura pulled you towards her as she walked backwards, falling back onto Karma’s bed and you eagerly crawled over her, one of your legs in between hers and the other on the outside so that your bare pussy could grind on her thigh while she ran her hands all over your body- mouths meeting in another passionate kiss. 

Karma watched from the sidelines, hand grasped around his very large, very swollen cock and his foreskin slid back and forth over the head, giving him some friction while he watched you girls grinding and writhing on the bed before him.

“Come over here,” you beckoned him, your voice a little hoarse from kissing Nakamura beneath you.

Karma walked forward until he was flush to the side of the bed and you hopped off Nakamura and immediately took his cock in your mouth, sucking on his head while Nakamura came up beside you and started kissing his shaft.

The red haired hottie groaned with excitement as he watched both you girls sucking and kissing his cock.

At hearing his groan you smirked and looked up at him, then pulled off his tip and started kissing Nakamura again.

“Kiss over his cock,” you whispered to her, taking to one side of his girth so she could take to the other, both licking his length then tongue kissing over his tip then back down again.

“Fuck!” he spat sexually, grabbing a fist full of your hair and Nakamura’s and forcing your faces together as he thrust his hips back and forth between your lips, getting his cock nice and slippery with your mixed saliva. 

Both of you moaned in response, allowing as much spit to mix as possible.

After coating himself well, he let you both go and you sat back then lay down with Nakamura crawling over you this time and sinking her wet pussy to yours, arching and rubbing her clit against yours while Karma watched once again.

“Come and kiss me,” you said to Karma as your hips ground back and forth against Nakamura’s. 

He made his way closer to your face, crawling onto the bed then kissing you passionately before grabbing you under the arms and yanking your body out from underneath Nakamura.

“Hey!” she snapped as you were swiftly removed, “give her back.”

“No. I want her on my dick,” Karma sneered, rolling onto his back and grabbing one of your legs to swing it over his body.

You lined your pussy up quickly with his swaying cock and sat down, enveloping his shaft with your very slick hole, taking him in one go.

“Oh shit,” you and Karma groaned, his nails digging into your thighs as you started to bounce on him.

Nakamura quickly climbed over his face and hovered her pussy over his lips which he readily delved his tongue into- making her body shudder as she leaned over to you and kissed you with need.

As you found a rhythm, your and Nakamura’s tongues played together, small mewls of delight rolling from her lips as Karma sucked and licked on her pussy- all three of you getting pleasured at the same time.

“I’m not gonna last much longer,” you panted urgently, “all this kissing, licking and fucking has my body keen.”

“Same,” Nakamura moaned, “the way our pussies slid against each other was amazing.”

“Mmhmm,” you moaned in reply increasing your bouncing, “fuck. Karma, tell me if you’re gonna cum, you need to pull out.”

Karma grunted in reply, his face still buried into Nakamura’s pussy. 

You and Nakamura kissed again as your fingers found her nipples.

“Oh, fuck, yes, tug on them,” she moaned, squealing with delight as you grabbed her pert buds and tugged them firmly.

“Oh god that looks so good!” you mewled, eyes glued to her chest.

She reached across and tugged on your nipples too, making your body shudder as you bucked even harder onto Karma’s cock.

“Oh fuck, I’m cumming,” you groaned, moaning louder as you reached the peak.

Nakamura started moaning more too, one of her hands leaving your nipple so that she could hold onto the side of Karma’s face and rock back and forth harder. 

Like an erotic melody, you both came, moaning repeatedly as you had your releases.

You had just finished when Karma tapped your thigh and you quickly lifted off, barely getting clear before he came hard, squirting all over his lower abdomen while Nakamura still sat on his face, panting and grinning from ear to ear.

“Well that was something I never expected to happen,” you panted from where you had landed on hands and knees on the bed.

“Same,” Nakamura replied, still on Karma’s face.

“You ever gonna get off?” you asked her with a chuckle, gesturing to how she was still sitting on Karma’s face, “I think he’s dead.”

“Wahh?!” she suddenly gasped, jumping up, “don’t give my pussy a hickey!”

“The fuck?” You burst out laughing.

“Figured that I may as well, since there was nothing else to do down there,” Karma replied cheekily as he sat up and wiped his mouth with the back of his hand, “but Y/N… I want you up on my face next time.”

“Yeah, and I wanna be between your thighs,” Nakamura leered.

“Ugh, what do I do with you guys,” you replied with a playful eye roll.

~ END ~

<<< Who Helped Who – Kaminari x Fem!Reader x Shinsou

Snake Bite – Cobra (Erik the snake charmer) x Fem!Reader >>>